Well, a Muslim had sent this person a message saying that Muhammad is mentioned in the Song of Solomon, so they were wanting to know how to respond. In the Old Testament there are many references. Naturally, no one expects a love poem to be part of the Book revealed by God Almighty. The Muslim attempt to find "Muhammad" by name in the Song of Solomon 5:16 is a prime example of eisegesis, of reading something entirely out of context into a verse of the Bible. Is Amos 8:11-12 a prediction of the Great Apostasy? Prophet Muhammad (s) is mentioned in the Bible by name many times but twice by the name of Muhammad, once in the Songs of Solomon and once in Haggai 2. Membership is required to comment. This fact alone should be enough to cast doubts on the claim that Solomon wrote the Song in admiration of his sweetheart — i.e. which make the claim that Muhammad is found in the Song of Solomon. Muhammad (pbuh) is from among the brethren of Moses (pbuh). A third party, or chorus, occasionally addresses the lovers. To them, what the writer said was only a symbolic husk for a deeper spiritual meaning that the reader must discover. The verse reads: His speech is most sweet, and he is altogether desirable. Here, I quote the learned view of a Christian Bible scholar on the Song of Solomon: There is no doubt that the Song of Solomon has a unique place among the books of the Bible … Thank you for contacting About Islam with your question. Some Muslims argue that this should be understood as the name Muhammad. The author of this video attempts to be humorous in giving his answer. Zakir Hussain vs. Samuel Green: Muhammad in the Bible – Debate ; With the foregoing in perspective, we want to look at this claim from a different angle, one that seeks to examine this assertion in light of the respective theology espoused by Solomon and contrast that to the teachings of Muhammad. The Song is apparently sung by Solomon in admiration of one woman, and it depicts faithful love to that woman; but Solomon had 700 wives and 300 concubines (1 Kings 11:3). Joined: Jul 6, 2008 Messages: 847 Likes Received: 0 Trophy Points: 26 Gender: Male Ratings Received: +2 / 0. Solomon's level of judgment, which the Quran says in this particular incident surpassed that of David, would characterize Solomon throughout his life. He didn’t even try to refute my points in my post but tried to make Muhammad into a type of Solomon. It follows logically that either the Song of Solomon is not divinely inspired, or there is a possibility of “Muhammadim” being a reference to the Last Prophet. Muhammad in the Bible! A famous one that they try to use is Song of Solomon 5:16. Christians have incorrectly translated the name “Muhammad” to something else, which will be shown as well, but the prophecy also gives a description of Prophet Muhammad … From a religious point of view: (1) it does not teach any doctrine; nor does it even mention God; (2) it does not reprove us for any error on our part; (3) it does not offer us any sort of correction; and (4) it does not guide us into righteousness; rather it gives sensuous descriptions of physical intimacy in a frank language in a Book of God. It should have been “the Praised One” — that is the correct meaning of “Muhammadim”. A fifth passage alleged to be a reference to Muhammad is found in Song of Solomon 5:16, where it is claimed that Muhammad is actually referred to by name in Hebrew. (Greg W. Parsons: “Guidelines for Understanding and Utilizing the Song of Songs,” Bibliotheca Sacra 156:624 (October-December 1999):399-422; quoted by Dr. Thomas L. Constable in his Notes on Song of Solomon). This is what Muslims are quick to point out. The Arabs are the descendants of Ishmail (pbuh) and the Jews are the descendants of Isaac (pbuh). The book consists of a dialogue between Solomon, his Shulamite bride-to-be, and the “daughters of Jerusalem,” with perhaps even God interjecting His comment (5:1b), as well as the Shulamite’s brothers (8:8-9). Muslim arguments. Here is his article: Muhammad in the Song of Songs. The term used in 5:16 that Muslims claim refers to Muhammad is also used in 2:3 to refer to the Shula… It is strongly recommended to read it all, and to understand the context (which is so not related to Muhammad neither to Islam). Prev Bible Topics Next . One excellent exegete called it “the most obscure book in the Old Testament” (Franz Delitzsch: Biblical Commentary on the Song of Songs and Ecclesiastes, quoted by Dr. Thomas L. Constable in his Notes on Song of Solomon). Song of Songs - A commentary on the complete book Song of Songs 5:16 The Lovely One Muhammad in the Bible (Songs 5:16)? As you have said, one of these prophetic verses is from the Song of Solomon. The world premiere video event of: The absolute truth about Muhammad in the bible: Rabbis who acknowledging the fact and readers who may never know! This book has received more varied interpretations than perhaps any other book in the Bible. Abraham (pbuh) had two sons: Ishmail and Isaac (pbut). Now, let us take a closer look at the verse quoted: [His mouth is most sweet: yea, he is altogether lovely. Song of Solomon 5:16. Let me state this clearly: Muhammad is not to be found in the pages of sacred scripture whether it be the Old or New Testament. Hosted by Muslim scholars have noted clear and undeniable prophecies found in the Bible (both in the. The book consists of a dialogue between Solomon, his Shulamite bride-to-be, and the “daughters of Jerusalem,” with perhaps even God interjecting His comment (5:1b), as well as the Shulamite’s brothers (8:8-9). It is also interesting to note: Many Muslims are "outraged" that something like the Song of Songs by Solomon which is a love song and sometimes very open in its erotic language could be part of the Word of God, the Bible. And then the love story suddenly takes on new meanings which it did not possess before. This means that the Christians have to take one of the two reasonable positions: Either they should consider the Song of Songs as non-canonical and reject it as possessing any scriptural value, or they should be prepared to accept it as an allegory, where language is used symbolically. Let us consider this question from the Christian point of view: The Christian scholars quote the following verse from Paul’s Second Epistle to Timothy as giving clear criteria for judging inspired scripture: [All scripture is given by inspiration of God, and is profitable for doctrine, for reproof, for correction, for instruction in righteousness.] Before we explain the context and meaning of the quoted verse, we need to understand the subject of the Song of Solomon and why it is considered a holy book inspired by God Almighty. And among those who have cared to examine the Islamic evidences were unbiased persons who were eventually convinced of the truth of Islam and have subsequently become Muslims. The word is in adjective form and can be found in other places in the Bible. The only possible apology for the inclusion of the Song in the Bible can come from the view that it is an allegory. Iam from India,My dobut is on bible verse i.e,song of solomon 5:16 In Hebrew Bible here muhammadim word is there.But my freind who knows hebrew he says that this muhammad is not a complete word.It is a combination of two hebrew words i.e,Ma+Amad, Here Ma is a Quetion Tag, Amad is a root word, Ma means How much,more(Altogether),what Amad means Lovely. The Song of Solomon is a series of lyrical poems organized as a lengthy dialogue between a young woman and her lover. SO Be not in any Prejudice and Accept The Truth . Which of all the Protestants denominations is the correct church. Question: “Does the Bible prophesy the coming of Muhammad?” Answer: There are three primary passages in the Bible that Muslims often point to as prophecies of the coming of Muhammad: Deuteronomy 18:15-22, Song of Solomon 5:16, and John 16:5-11. First, in regards to Deuteronomy 18:15-22, the immediate context of this passage refers back to verses 9-14. But English translations have "He is altogether lovely" instead of the real truth. You need to insist that, … Further, the claim that Muhammad is intended in the verse completely disregards the context and message of the book of Song of Solomon. Christians who know their Bibles have never seen it, but Zakr Naik says it is in the Hebrew Bible. Machmadim means "beloved, desire, goodly, lovely, pleasant thing". The original Hebrew Bible has “Muhammadim” in the place of “altogether lovely”, but the translators rendered it “altogether lovely”. >>>>> Nama Muhammad Saw dalam Song Of Solomon >>>>> Muhammad (pbuh) is mentioned by name in the Song of Solomon 5:16. Further, the claim that Muhammad is intended in the verse completely disregards the context and message of the book of Song of Solomon. Now, after considering the whole of the Song of Solomon and the context of the verse, we can say that if we take the Song as an allegory, and the epithet, “Muhammadim” as a description of “the beloved”, it is possible that the beloved is someone for whom a nation — or the world — was waiting (for instance). Before we explain the context and meaning of the quoted verse, we need to understand the subject of the Song of Solomon and why it is considered a holy book inspired by God Almighty. Question: "Does the Bible prophesy the coming of Muhammad?" Some writers believe it presents the reader with the “greatest hermeneutical challenge in the Old Testament”. It says in the Hebrew language Bibles "He is Muhammad." (Song of Solomon 5:16). Answer: There are three primary passages in the Bible that Muslims often point to as prophecies of the coming of Muhammad: Deuteronomy 18:15-22, Song of Solomon 5:16, and John 16:5-11. They (with very few exceptions) do not study the context of the expression as found in the present Bible. A famous one that they try to use is Song of Solomon 5:16. Some writers believe it presents the reader with the “greatest hermeneutical challenge in the Old Testament”. I think this shows how desperate Muslims are to paint Muhammad into pre-Islamic texts. Prev Bible Topics Next . Muslim scholars have noted clear and undeniable prophecies found in the Bible (both in the Old and New Testaments) about the coming of the final prophet. The Christian claim about the Song of Solomon, that it just tells a good love story, seems to contradict their defense of the Song as divinely inspired as the rest of the Bible. (2 Timothy 3:16, KJV). Muhammad (PBU) in Solomon's Song 5:16. Many Bible commentators have tried to solve its mystery but cannot put the pieces of the puzzle together because they have excluded the Prophet Muhammad peace be upon him. started by BigAk, Mar 4, 2009. Here, I quote the learned view of a Christian Bible scholar on the Song of Solomon: This book has received more varied interpretations than perhaps any other book in the Bible. The context of the whole Song of Solomon is about human love or human sexual desire. Viewed from this angle, it would be wrong to take the Song of Solomon literally. The Hebrew word used in this verse is Mahamaddim. At other places, other names like Ahmed and Mustafa have been used. O daughters of Jerusalem,” (Song of Solomon 5:16). Let me state this clearly: Muhammad is not to be found in the pages of sacred scripture whether it be the Old or New Testament. Islamic apologists since the early days of Islam have tried to paint Muhammad into the Bible. Shaikh Deedat has talked about this before in his booklet "Muhammad in the Bible." I don't think Solomon was in love with Muhammad >.>..... @nish- The name Muhammad means "Praised, or the praised one". Therefore, whatever is believed to have been revealed or inspired by God must serve one of the four purposes: Either (1) it must teach us doctrine; (2) it must reprove us for our error; (3) it offers us correction; or (4) it guides us into righteousness. One excellent exegete called it “the most obscure book in the Old Testament” (Franz Delitzsch: This fact alone should be enough to cast doubts on the claim that, To them, what the writer said was only a symbolic husk for a deeper spiritual meaning that the reader must discover. Christian Web Hosting. Ironically, this claim comes even in the face of the prevailing Islamic contention that the Bible has been corrupted, and thus cannot be relied upon as an accurate record of God’s Word. Page Discussion. In English, the verse reads: “His mouth is most sweet, yes, he is altogether lovely. The word translated here “wholly desirable” is the word “machamadim.” The word sounds a lot like “Muhammad,” though it is in the plural form. It follows logically that either the Song of Solomon is not divinely inspired, or there is a possibility of “Muhammadim” being a reference to the Last Prophet, Muhammad (peace be upon him). 5.Now, it may suprise you to know that among the learned men of Judiasm, many consider the rendering to be "that prophet" for example Midrash Rabbi Shimon bar Yochai, or you can check out Rabbi Mort from mahi ministries on you tube. Please keep in touch. Indeed, the difficulty of providing it a meaningful interpretation has caused some Christian readers to doubt its status as a part of scripture. At the same time, “Muhammadim” happens to contain the name of the final prophet (peace be upon him). a single person — glorifying fidelity and sincerity in love. The ending letters im is a plural of respect, majesty and grandeur, Just as in Elohim (the God). It is not so long. Nevertheless, Muslim polemicist Zakir Naik claims that Muhammad is mentioned by name in the Hebrew text of Song of Solomon 5:16. Machmadim is also used in reference to Ezekiel's wife ( Ezekiel 24:16,18). (Greg W. Parsons: “Guidelines for Understanding and Utilizing the Song of Songs,”, Viewed from this angle, it would be wrong to take the Song of, At the same time, “Muhammadim” happens to contain the name of. According to this Muslim (and many others, including Muslim apologist Zakir Naik), Muhammad, the founder of Islam, can be found in Song of Solomon 5:16. On the contrary to being the weakest evidence , Song of Songs 5:16 give very strong evidence for the prophecy of prophet Muhammad (p) in the Bible. Chiefly, because a love story for the sake of a love story does not have any place in scripture. Muhammad is NOT in the Bible. Of course, all Christians will swiftly deny it. The first poem is spoken by the young maiden, who longs to be near her lover and enjoy his kisses. On examination, we can find the Song of Solomon failing to pass any of the above criteria. I want to underscore this point again. The most significant is Song of Solomon, chapter 5, verse 16. She explains that she has a dark complexion because her family sends her to work in the vineyards. This is my beloved, and this is my friend, O daughters of Jerusalem.] First, in regards to Deuteronomy 18:15-22, the immediate context of this passage refers back to verses 9-14. Please continue feeding your curiosity, and find more info in the following links: Who Is “Muhammadim” In The Song of Solomon? The Christian contention is that the context does not warrant any one to claim that there is a clear reference here to the final prophet (peace be upon him). Islamic apologists since the early days of Islam have tried to paint Muhammad into the Bible. The word is in plural form; White even boldly claim that this is the weakest argument the muslims have on finding prophet Muhammad in the Bible. Recently a Muslim apologist named Faiz tried to refute a blog post that I made about Muhammad in Song of Solomon 5:16. - Song of Solomon - video dailymotion The verse reads: His speech is most sweet, and he is altogether desirable. As you have said, one of these prophetic verses is from the Song of Solomon. Muhammad in the Bible: Song of Solomon. Muhammad SAW is clearly mentioned in Bible Song of Solomon 5:16 The Speaker in This Audio is Himself a Jewish Rabbi and he is better know how to Spell The word MHMD In Arabic it is spell as Muhammad . I hope this answers your questions. There are many books, webpages etc. The Song of Solomon contains beautiful and sensuous poetry expressing romantic love between a young man (a shepherd 1:7) and.a young woman (a shepherdess 1:8). There is no doubt that the Song of Solomon has a unique place among the books of the Bible because it is a love poem. Discussion in 'TurnToIslam Lounge !' She searches for her lover, comparing him to a wandering shepherd, and the chorus encourages her to follow the flocks to his tent. They contend that the small differences in pronunciation are irrelevant and that it is in the … Now what remains is for us to specify where in the Bible to find mention of our prophet. A key theme is that marriage is a gift from God to be … Yes, you read that correctly. Offline BigAk Junior Member. This verse mentions our prophet by name. The majority of interpreters favor this view. Jews use to sing Song of Songs every Friday evening. Does the name Muhammad appear in the Bible? The Song of Solomon has always been a mysterious love story. Ḥikmah ( Wisdom ), according to Muslim tradition, would always be associated with Solomon, who would later even be referred to as Sulaimān al-Ḥakīm ( سُلَيْمَان ٱلْحَكِيْم , "Solomon the Wise"). Arabs are brethren of Jews. And as has been argued above, there is a strong case for that. When these verses are quoted, the usual response of many Jews and Christians is a staunch denial of any such possibility. (Youtube Video) Another video. The Song of Songs are a love song. Instead of the final prophet ( peace be upon him ) Muhammad in Song of Solomon failing to pass of... Who longs to be near her lover Song in the Song of Solomon has always a! Points in my post but tried to make Muhammad into the Bible. love poem to be her... To them, what the writer said was only a symbolic husk for a spiritual! She explains that she has a dark complexion because her family sends her to work in Bible! My friend, O daughters of Jerusalem. majesty and grandeur, Just as in Elohim ( God. Above, there is a strong case for that that this should be understood muhammad in the bible song of solomon the name of whole... `` beloved, and this is what Muslims are quick to point out woman! Challenge in the present Bible. Accept the Truth that, … the of! The real Truth the only possible apology for the sake of a love poem to be humorous in giving answer!, because a love story suddenly takes on new meanings which it not... Used in reference to Ezekiel 's wife ( Ezekiel 24:16,18 ) instead of the Great Apostasy of Islam tried! That it is in the Hebrew language Bibles `` he is Muhammad. of scripture Song of Songs Friday! Accept the Truth 5, verse 16 Deuteronomy 18:15-22, the claim that Muhammad is intended in the Hebrew.... Bible. the inclusion of the above criteria was only a symbolic for. Name of the real Truth the Arabs are the descendants of Ishmail ( pbuh ) it would wrong! In other places, other names like Ahmed and Mustafa have been “ the Praised ”... As found in the Old Testament ” descendants of Isaac ( pbut ) the expression as in... Meaning that the reader with the “ greatest hermeneutical challenge in the Bible ''! Who know their Bibles have never seen it, but Zakr Naik says it is in the Bible come! Any other book in the Song of Solomon 5:16 ) Christians will swiftly deny it to pass any of real... Bible. woman and her lover a plural of respect, majesty grandeur... Reader with the “ greatest hermeneutical challenge in the Song of Solomon is about human love or human sexual.... Is the correct meaning of “ Muhammadim ” says in the Song in the Hebrew language Bibles `` is! Exceptions ) do not study the context of the Song of Solomon 5:16 the... Testament ” says in the Bible to find mention of our prophet Song... With your question the view that it is in the Bible can come the... The usual response of many Jews and Christians is a strong case for that ending... In the Song of Solomon, chapter 5, verse 16 is in verse... Expects a love poem to be part of the final prophet ( peace upon...: his speech is most sweet, and he is altogether lovely '' instead of real. Jews use to sing Song of Solomon early days of Islam have tried to refute my in. To paint Muhammad into the Bible., ” ( Song of Solomon literally in to... Lovely, pleasant thing '' “ his mouth is most sweet, yes, he is.. Word is in the Hebrew text of Song of Solomon literally quoted, the immediate of. A series of lyrical poems organized as a part of the final prophet ( peace be him... Writers believe it presents the reader with the “ greatest hermeneutical challenge the! Who longs to be near her lover and enjoy his kisses: Muhammad in the verse reads his...